Words by JANE CROWTHER


You really can see everything in Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s slippery, form-flitting, disingenuous and utterly fascinating documentary. But you also can see nothing. Playing with our concept of truth, facts and performance, Fielder and Oppenheim present what seems to be a fly-on-the-wall doc where the droll Fielder moves into the home of convicted tech figurehead Elizabeth Holmes in the month before she enters prison to serve a sentence of 11 years. There he interacts with Holmes and her intense husband Billy, observing them as two unblinking people untethered from reality and professing to have nothing to hide. But as Fielder becomes more entrenched his objectivity is compromised, the honesty of Holmes appears even more opaque despite her much-memed truthful confessions, and what is not shown becomes an elephant in the room. 

Amanda Seyfried, Christopher Abbott, Nathan Fielder
A24

While the zeroing-in cameras capture Billy fully naked in the shower and his coercive manner in how scrambled eggs are made, and mics pick up private conversations, it becomes increasingly clear that what we understand as a traditional expose or documentary is warping before our eyes and only uncertainty remains. Playing like a thriller, You Can See Everything has two separate acts and a number of ‘plot twists’ – all of which leave viewers on shifting sands of trust. What is real? What is not revealed? Is this performance? Who is manipulating whom? 

Amanda Seyfried, Christopher Abbott, Nathan Fielder
Chris Maggio /A24

Add a meta element in the second half (which is best discovered rather than spoiled) and this movie becomes exhilaratingly bewildering. Who says there are no new stories anymore? In Fielder and Oppenheim’s hands (with the help of an MVP actor with prior links to Holmes) a documentary evolves to become a film that offers absolutely no answers, but does invite audiences into what can only be described as an experience. There’s the sense of being a rube at a carnival while watching: there’s illusion at work but where and how is impossible to detect. But the thrill of the show is worth the entrance fee.

To share specifics is to risk that experience but suffice to say, this is bold, ingenious work that warrants every minute of its three-hour running time and will linger long in the mind after lights up. In blurring the lines between truth and fiction, You Can See Everything asks us to question everything – not just this film but global politics, media discourse and the narratives we all put into the world. It’s a Russian doll, sleight-of-hand film that changes the game in art form and could upset awards season. At one point in the film Fielder tells Holmes about a trick by magician David Blaine, explaining that an icepick-through-the-hand illusion is genius because he presents it as a trick, while doing it for real. The magic, Fielder suggests, is in the fact that Blaine plays with presentation. It’s a reality, dressed as a trick that is presented as a reality, and the rush is in not knowing the difference. It’s a similar Legerdemain at work here. See it to (not) believe it…

Amanda Seyfried, Christopher Abbott, Nathan Fielder
Lance Oppenheim /A24

Words by JANE CROWTHER
Images courtesy of A24
You Can See Everything is in cinemas now